I’M DYING’—THE HEARTBREAKING WORDS ECHOING FROM THE PITCH-BLACK ABYSS! The physical fall was terrifying, but what happened next is what is truly keeping local residents awake at night. As witnesses rushed to the edge of the newly exposed hole, the late-night silence of Fifth Avenue was completely shattered… From the bottom of that 15-foot deep dark shaft, Donike Gocaj was desperately screaming, “I’m dying,” over and over again into the darkness. Bystanders could only listen in pure, helpless panic as her voice echoed up from the concrete grid, waiting for emergency crews to arrive. What hidden, violent forces were acting inside that utility vault to cause such immediate, agonizing distress? The sheer weight of those final words has left the entire community in deep mourning… 📌 Full story in the comments

Donike Gocaj, grandmother who ‘dropped’ into NYC manhole, hauntingly screamed ‘I’m dying’ — as witness claims there was nothing blocking it off

Woman dies after falling into open manhole in Midtown

A devoted mother died in every New Yorker’s worst nightmare after she “dropped” into a manhole in Manhattan late Monday — desperately screaming “I’m dying” as she waited for help to arrive.

Donike Gocaj, 56, plummeted about 10 or 15 feet down into the uncovered utility hole near East 52nd Street and Fifth Avenue after she got out of her parked Mercedes-Benz, police and witnesses said Tuesday.

“She was just in the hole screaming that she was dying,” said Carl Wood, a bystander who watched as the horror unfolded around 11:20 p.m. in front of the flagship Cartier store.

Donike Gocaj (left) with her daughter Rina (right) and two young boys.
Donike Gocaj (left) died after falling into a Manhattan manhole Monday night.Facebook / Donika Gocaj
Black Mercedes-Benz SUV next to an uncovered manhole at a street intersection blocked off by orange cones and barriers, with two police officers standing nearby.
Gocaj fell about 10 to 15 feet down the hole to her death.FNTV

“Over and over she was like, ‘I’m dying, I’m dying.’”

The open Con Edison maintenance hole was just feet away from the SUV’s door, recalled Wood, a fire safety specialist on his way to work — who said he sprinted over and called 911 as Gocaj screamed for help from the bottom.

Gocaj’s haunting screams had stopped by the time FDNY emergency responders arrived minutes later, Wood told The Post.

They pulled her unconscious, unresponsive body from the hole and rushed her to New York-Presbyterian/Weill Cornell Medical Center, where she later died from her injuries, officials said.

Con Ed workers repair a manhole at 52nd St. and 5th Ave. in Manhattan.
Gocaj fell in shortly after exiting her parked Mercedes-Benz SUV.Robert Mecea for New York Post
Scene of an uncovered manhole after a driver plunged to her death.
Con Edison workers inspecting the scene of the accident.FNTV

The freak incident remains under investigation, with several lingering major questions — including exactly why the manhole was uncovered.

A representative from Con Ed said a passing truck seems to have dislodged the manhole’s cover — less than 15 minutes before Gocaj arrived and parked along the avenue.

“We have reviewed video footage from the area which suggests that the cover was dislodged after a multi-axle truck turning onto 52nd Street from 5th Avenue drove over it. Approximately 12 minutes later, the person involved in the incident parked her car nearby,” the spokesperson said in a statement.

“We are reviewing the details, and while this is a rare occurrence, manhole covers can get displaced by heavy vehicles. Our thoughts remain with her family, and safety remains our top priority.”

Con Edison workers repairing a manhole cover.
Con Ed workers repair the manhole cover at 52nd Street and 5th Avenue.Robert Mecea for New York Post
A Con Edison worker repairs a manhole on a city street.
A worker sealing the manhole cover back on early Sunday.Robert Mecea for New York Post

What Gocaj, of Briarcliff Manor in Westchester County, was doing in the luxurious commercial area late at night remained unclear Tuesday.

Her vehicle appeared to be parked in a “no standing” zone near a bike lane, and outside the Cartier store that closed at 7 p.m., photos showed.

Wood, the witness, said Gocaj took only a couple steps forward and dropped into the hole after closing her car door. She didn’t appear to be “distracted” or on her phone, he said.

Gocaj with her grandchildren.
Gocaj with her grandchildren.Facebook/Donika Gocaj

“You know, it was like in those cartoons. She just disappeared into the hole,” he said.

“The cover was right next to the hole. It was just off the hole … the cover was just sitting there — but there was no cones, there was no barricades, there was nothing.”

Other bystanders also desperately tried to help the screaming Gocaj, Wood said.

One man attempted to let himself down so she could grab his legs to pull herself up, while another brought over a ladder that proved to be too short to reach her, Wood said.

Gocaj with her son and daughter-in-law at their wedding in 2025.
Gocaj with her son and daughter-in-law at their wedding in 2025.Facebook/Donika Gocaj

While the fall wasn’t that far, Wood said it seemed like it was incredibly hot in the hole and that Gocaj appeared to be “in a puddle of water.”

“Like maybe steaming hot water. So I’m not sure, but I’m assuming maybe she was burning up down there. Bad air down there,” Wood said, recalling firefighters wearing masks and swearing as they pulled her out.

EMS and FDNY arrived within minutes, Wood said, but by then, he said, they “didn’t even hear her screaming anymore.”

Donika Gocaj with her daughter Rina
Gocaj with her daughter Rina in a Facebook photo.Facebook/Donika Gocaj

Wrappers for burn sheets used to cover burn victims were still visible on the ground Tuesday.

The Office of Chief Medical Examiner said it was investigating the cause of death.

The horror rattled New Yorkers working in the busy Midtown area, as well as others who came to see what happened.

“Somebody messed up,” said Alex, a union carpenter taking his lunch break. “Usually they are covered up, they are protected. I’ve never seen a manhole by itself open — never.”

A packaged "BURN SHEET" found on a street.
A burn sheet wrapper on the ground near the manhole where Gocaj fell to her death.James Messerschmidt for the NY Post
Three manhole covers and two traffic cones are seen on a street in Manhattan, with a white ConEdison van driving past.
A Con Edison van stationed near the manhole where Gocaj died on May 19, 2026.James Messerschmidt for the NY Post

“This is horrible, it’s a horrible mistake,” said Michael D., 56, who has worked in the area for two decades and noted he tries to stay alert.

“I have eyes at the back of my head on the streets. Too many things happening.”

Susan Siroto, a licensed clinical social worker, took a cab to the scene while on her way to the dentist.

“It’s another horrible sort of incident of things that are kind of unanticipated or unexpected, that are taking place around the city these days,” she said.

“I feel terrible for them,” she said, referring to the victim’s family.  “It’s something that could have been avoided. It didn’t have to happen.”

Gocaj’s family declined to comment.

Related Posts