If you’re a fan of Wednesday, you probably remember the iconic dance scene from Season 1, set to Lady Gaga’s “Bloody Mary.” It became a viral sensation, with fans everywhere talking about it and recreating the quirky, unexpected moves Jenna Ortega brought to life as Wednesday Addams. The scene was spontaneous, out-of-character, and super fun. But now, as Wednesday Season 2 has aired, a new dance moment has fans talking again—and this time, the reaction isn’t quite as enthusiastic.

In the latest season, Enid and Agnes share a dramatic dance scene to Gaga’s “The Dead Dance,” and many fans are drawing comparisons between the two. The question is: Did the show try too hard to recreate the magic of that viral moment? According to some Wednesday viewers, this new scene feels forced and a bit too obvious. It almost feels like the writers and producers knew they had to throw in another dance sequence to keep the momentum going, especially given the overwhelming popularity of the Season 1 moment.

One Reddit user put it bluntly, “This feels so forced and obvious. The 2022 one was spontaneous and fun, but this feels like it HAD to be there.” The magic of that first dance was the surprise factor—the last thing we expected was Wednesday Addams, of all people, dancing to a pop song, and it made the moment unforgettable. The question now is whether the new scene can live up to the energy of the original.

But it’s not just the dance itself that has fans buzzing. Some also suspect that the inclusion of Lady Gaga’s “The Dead Dance” is part of a bigger marketing push. Wednesday producers struck a deal with Gaga for her cameo as Rosaline Rotwood, and Gaga’s new song conveniently released right around the same time as Season 2. As one fan pointed out, it feels like a mutually beneficial marketing moment: “It’s a Hollywood reach-around circlejerk.”

Regardless of whether you think the dance was necessary or not, the performers behind the moment—Emma Myers and Evie Templeton—deserve major credit. Emma, who has a background in gymnastics, and Evie, a trained ballet dancer, were both up for the challenge. Even without Gaga’s involvement, the scene shows off their impressive talents. But while the dance moves may have been spectacular, fans are still wondering: Was this dance moment truly necessary, or just a forced attempt to recapture lightning in a bottle?

The scene also sparked some controversy among fans who felt the writers were reusing old tricks from Season 1. One fan commented, “I’m more pointing towards the writers about recycling Season 1 scripts instead of taking a new road.” It’s true that Season 2 has a lot to live up to after the massive success of the first season, and some fans feel like this dance move was a mere attempt to replicate the magic, instead of letting the show evolve naturally.

As another fan mentioned, it’s hard to see how the dance moment could have worked organically in Season 2—especially since Wednesday’s first dance was part of a romantic moment with Tyler. So how does the show justify a second dance? It’s a tough task, and Wednesday certainly tries its best to make it work.

While it’s clear that Lady Gaga’s new single is a hit and the dance scene was visually stunning, it seems fans are divided on whether it really hit the mark. What do you think? Was the Wednesday dance moment in Season 2 a necessary homage to the viral “Bloody Mary” dance, or did the show try too hard to capture the same magic?

Let us know in the comments below!